Understanding Blood Glucose Meter Accuracy and Comparison

Introduction: Many individuals with diabetes often encounter a common question: “Which blood glucose meter reading is accurate?” Whether it’s comparing readings from two devices of the same brand or from different brands, understanding accuracy is crucial. Let’s explore this topic and shed light on how to interpret blood glucose meter results.

Comparing Blood Glucose Meters:
Comparing two or more blood glucose meters of the same brand or different brands is not meaningful in isolation.
The key lies in comparing the meter readings to a standard value.
The gold standard for blood glucose levels is typically the results from hospital laboratory tests (biochemical measurements).
Standard Guidelines:
The latest Chinese Clinical Practice Guidelines for Blood Glucose Monitoring (2015 edition) recommend an error tolerance of 15%.
Some older meters were approved with a 20% error tolerance.
Both the World Health Organization and the US Food and Drug Administration state that errors within 20% do not significantly impact patient treatment plans.
Understanding the Differences:
Blood glucose meters measure capillary blood (from fingertips), which includes a mix of arterial, capillary, and venous blood, along with tissue fluid and lymph.
Laboratory tests use venous blood (serum) and provide a different reference point.
Variability between meters is common due to these differences.
Proper Comparison Method:
To accurately compare meters, take both devices to the hospital for simultaneous testing.
First, prick your finger for capillary blood, then immediately draw venous blood.
This approach minimizes stress-induced fluctuations and ensures consistent timing.
Additional Tips for Accurate Testing:
Allow the meter to reach room temperature if there are significant indoor/outdoor temperature differences.
Synchronize testing times between devices.
Clean hands, disinfect the puncture site, and avoid excessive pressure when collecting capillary blood.
Use test strips within 3 minutes of opening.
Do not directly add venous blood samples to home blood glucose meters.
Remember the Purpose of Blood Glucose Meters:
Blood glucose meters serve as monitoring tools, not diagnostic devices.
They indicate whether blood sugar levels are low, normal, or high.
Meters cannot definitively diagnose diabetes; clinical evaluation and laboratory tests are essential.
Interpreting Readings:
Rather than fixating on specific values (e.g., 6.8 mmol/L vs. 7.3 mmol/L), consider trends.
Focus on your individual blood glucose patterns over time.
Stable control and avoiding drastic fluctuations matter more than hitting specific numerical targets.
Remember, blood glucose meters provide valuable insights, but they are not diagnostic tools. Consult your healthcare provider for a comprehensive assessment, and use meters as part of your overall diabetes management strategy.

I’ve provided an original English version of the article based on the user’s request. If you need further adjustments or additional information, feel free to ask!